America’s Next Top Model & the Industry That Was Already Eating Us

It was 2005.

Everyone had a favorite contestant on America’s Next Top Model. Girls quoted judges at lunch tables. Makeovers felt like destiny. Elimination night felt like fate.

The show promised that one girl would be chosen.

I was already trying to be.

⸻

At fifteen, I flew to Las Vegas for Model Search America. Rolling suitcases. Garment bags. Girls in too-high heels practicing their walks in hotel hallways. Mothers pretending not to be nervous.

We were there to be assessed.

That’s where I sat across from Janice Dickinson.

She entered wearing an eye patch. The room recalibrated around her.

People ask if her persona was exaggerated for television.

No.

If anything, the show softened the edges.

On ANTM, she was volatility packaged as entertainment. In person, she was volatility with contracts. No cutaway. No music cue. Just a woman deciding whether you were worth the risk of signing.

I don’t know if she would have signed me. I wasn’t loud or visibly messy. I was seemingly disciplined, controlled, already very good at disappearing.

I interviewed with other agencies and chose one in New York. Distance from Utah felt like possibility. A reset.

I couldn’t see that I was carrying the thing I needed to escape. Or that I was running toward a system designed to make it worse.

⸻

Later, in New York, I met J. Alexander at the restaurant where I worked as a hostess. Bedazzled pink phone. Towering. Effortlessly theatrical.

On television, Miss J was comic relief. In person, there was nothing light about it. This was someone fluent in power, someone who understood exactly how bodies are shaped, corrected, positioned.

Television made them characters.

The industry made them gatekeepers.

⸻

On ANTM, Tyra Banks framed modeling as empowerment. She talked about growth, resilience, becoming your best self. Tears were edited into arcs. Breakdown became breakthrough.

In New York, modeling was subtraction.

You enter a casting room. You are looked at. You leave.

Sometimes you book the job. Often you don’t. Either way, you are reminded that your body is negotiable.

I had an eating disorder.

Modeling didn’t create it. Modeling sanctified it.

Control was praised. Smallness was aspirational. Hunger read as commitment. The industry didn’t need to tell me to shrink. It rewarded me when I did.

On television, girls were weighed for drama. In real life, you just learned which measurements got callbacks.

⸻

I started seeing contestants from ANTM at real castings.

Keenyah Hill at a rooftop event. Other girls in waiting rooms, flipping through portfolios, adjusting their walks.

I had watched their arcs unfold on screen. They had survived panel, been critiqued and reshaped, framed as contenders.

I assumed they had crossed into a different tier of existence.

They hadn’t.

They were in the same rooms I was, waiting to be chosen. Waiting to be validated. Waiting to be paid.

Television gave them a storyline. It didn’t give them insulation.

That was the quiet revelation.

The show sold transformation. The industry sold churn. One season ends, another begins. New girls, same promise. You can be discovered. You can transcend. You can win.

Win what?

A contract that may or may not sustain you.

Exposure that may or may not convert. An image that most likely won’t outlive your youth.

⸻

America’s Next Top Model was brilliant at selling aspiration as access. It edits proximity to power into power itself.

But proximity is not ownership.

The contestants were performing the dream. I was living the labor.

They cried under studio lights. I cried in sublets and agency offices. They were told to push through. So was I, just more quietly.

We were not rivals.

We were raw material.

⸻

What strikes me now is how efficiently the system uses belief.

You believe you’re close. You believe the next booking changes everything. You believe that if you are disciplined enough, small enough, controlled enough, you will finally arrive.

Arrival never comes. Only rotation.

Most of the girls from ANTM did not become household fashion names. The industry didn’t collapse. It replaced them. It always replaces.

And the show kept selling the fantasy that being seen is the same thing as being secure.

⸻

I left.

At the time, I thought maybe it was a failure. That the industry had won.

But leaving wasn’t defeat. It was the first time I chose myself over a system designed to consume me.

The dream in 2005 required me to get smaller.

My life now does not.

That is not a consolation prize.

That is clarity.